Address
宁波研发园A区2栋12B17
聚贤街道,鄞州区,宁波市,浙江中国
Work Hours
周一 to 周五: 8:30AM - 10:30PM
周六 to 周日: 9:30AM - 10:30PM

Which stylus tip material for which workpiece? This article explains why ruby is the default, when to switch to silicon nitride for aluminum or zirconia for cast iron, and how to identify the correct thread system first.
“Hey, we’re measuring aluminium parts here and the stylus tip keeps going black. After a few dozen points it’s no good. Should we swap the ball?”
This is the most common question on any CMM shop floor. The operator stares at the black deposit on the stylus that won’t wipe off, and the first reaction is usually “the ruby ball is worn out, it needs replacing.” But with what? Some say “use silicon nitride for aluminium” from memory, some hear from the next workshop that “zirconia is for cast iron”, and others just buy a few of each ball material and try them one by one. Trial and error is cheap enough, but time is not — every stylus change means recalibration, and calibration itself introduces new uncertainty.
What’s worse, a wrong ball material choice is not always as visible as blackening. Aluminium chips from adhesive wear build up quietly on the ball, increasing the effective ball diameter and biasing the measurement results high. Cast-iron debris from abrasive wear scratches fine grooves into the ruby surface, degrading repeatability. By the time the data looks wrong, a whole batch may already be finished.
This article addresses a question that seems simple but is actually easy to get wrong: which stylus tip material should be used for which working conditions. We start with ruby, the default choice, and explain why it covers the vast majority of applications. We then break down adhesive wear in heavy-load scanning of aluminum parts and abrasive wear in heavy-load scanning of cast iron, clarifying the boundary conditions for silicon nitride and zirconia. It is important to stress that silicon nitride is not a universal solution—on steel it actually accelerates wear, so its use should be limited to aluminum. Likewise, zirconia’s applicability is also conditional on heavy-load scanning; not every cast iron part needs it.
After reading this, you should be able to answer at least three questions. First, does my application count as heavy-load scanning, and should I switch tip materials? Second, if I do switch, how do I choose between silicon nitride and zirconia, and on what basis? Third, when is it reliable to infer the tip material from the workpiece material, and when does that approach lead to misjudgment? We do not discuss price or compare brands—we only cover the specification system and selection logic. Every criterion we mention can be verified against the corresponding page in the official product catalog, so you can check it yourself at any time.
Choosing the right tip material improves stylus life and data stability; choosing the wrong one means the stylus cannot perform as intended. Let us begin with ruby, the default starting point.
The thread system follows the probe, not the machine brand. On the same CMM, changing the probe head or probe module can change the thread from M2 to M3, or even M4. Domestic CMM brands and some imported models use the Renishaw system for the probe head and controller; the Hexagon system has its own part numbering scheme. So saying “I use brand X” does not tell you the thread size. The correct sequence is: identify the probe or probe head model first, then determine the thread, then the stylus ball diameter and length.
Taking Renishaw’s official catalogue as an example, M2 thread is used for probes such as TP2, TP20, TP200 and REVO™; M3 thread is used for TP1 and TP6 manual probes, as well as the SP25M scanning probe and REVO™; M4 thread is reserved for the high-accuracy TP7M and machine-tool probing systems; M5 thread is used for the highest-accuracy scanning probes. Hexagon’s catalogue is also split into two sections – touch-trigger and scanning. The touch-trigger section covers M2, M3 and M4 threads; the scanning section covers D2 (threadless), M3 and M5 threads. Both catalogues follow the same logic: the thread is a physical property of the probe interface and has no direct correspondence to the machine brand.
The practical way to identify the thread is straightforward: find the model number printed on the probe and check it against the official catalogue. For example, a Renishaw Equator comparator uses M2 styli when fitted with the TM25-20 trigger module, and M3 styli when the SM25-2 scanning module is installed — the same machine takes different threads depending on the module. In the Hexagon catalogue, M2 threaded styli and accessories cover pages 14 to 21, M3 covers pages 26 to 30, and M4 takes up only page 32; the scanning section also lists D2 unthreaded styli (page 38) and M5 threaded styli (pages 51 to 64). These page counts themselves show that M4 is a “niche but dedicated” size at both companies: Renishaw uses it for the TP7M and machine tool probes, while Hexagon devotes just one page to it. That does not mean either company undervalues M4 — it simply serves different applications.
Once the thread is settled, the choice of stylus ball material comes into play. Ruby is the default starting point for the vast majority of applications — not out of habit, but because of the material’s properties. Synthetic ruby is a high-purity alumina single crystal grown by the Verneuil method at around 2000 °C, then cut and ground into high-sphericity spheres. Its surface is extremely smooth, it has high compressive strength, resists mechanical corrosion, and its low density keeps the tip mass small, which avoids false triggers caused by machine motion or vibration. The official catalogue puts it this way: “there are very few applications for which ruby is unsuitable.” That statement carries weight because it positions ruby as the benchmark, not just one option among many.
The physical property data for ruby tells the story. Sphericity deviation is 0.13 µm, hardness is 2300 HV, compressive strength is 2100 MPa, fracture toughness K1c is 1, and thermal expansion coefficient is 4.5×10⁻⁶/°C. These values appear alongside silicon nitride and zirconia in the official table: ruby has the highest hardness, mid-range compressive strength, and the lowest fracture toughness. Low fracture toughness means the material is more brittle, but since ruby is a single-crystal material, brittleness is not a drawback in stylus tip applications where compressive loading dominates. High hardness and high surface finish are the key advantages.
Another common mistake in stylus tip material selection is working backwards from the workpiece material. Some people hear that silicon nitride is used for aluminium parts and assume every aluminium measurement requires a different tip material; they hear that zirconia is used for cast iron and conclude that ruby must never touch cast iron. This ignores the premise of heavy-duty scanning. The correct decision order is: first confirm the probe model, then the thread size, then the ball diameter and length, and only then assess whether a different tip material is needed for the specific application. If the thread does not match, the right tip material will not fit; if the ball diameter is insufficient, the correct material can still cause false triggers from the shaft rubbing against the workpiece.
Ball diameter and length selection follows a similar logic. The official selection rules are threefold: use the shortest stylus that meets the application, minimise the number of joints, and use the largest ball possible. The longer the stylus, the greater the bending and deflection, and the lower the accuracy. Each extension bar added introduces another potential bending and deflection point. A larger ball increases the clearance between the ball and the stylus stem, reducing false triggers caused by the stem rubbing against the workpiece. A larger ball also averages out the effects of workpiece surface roughness. These rules are applied in parallel with ball material selection, not sequentially—the thread determines whether the stylus can be mounted, the ball diameter and length determine which size to use, and the ball material determines whether it is suitable for the specific application.
Ruby is the default starting point because its application range is broad enough. In the official catalogue, ruby-ball styli cover the full M2 to M5 range, with stem options in stainless steel, tungsten carbide, ceramic or carbon fibre. Ball diameters are available in various sizes; refer to the official data sheet for specifics. The specification table in the Hexagon catalogue lists part number, material, overall length, ball diameter, stem diameter, effective working length and weight. Material codes are R for ruby ball, TC for tungsten carbide stem, SS for stainless steel stem, and CE for ceramic. These fields and codes are common to both systems, indicating that the specification system for ruby styli is highly standardised.
One detail worth noting: in the official naming convention, stylus descriptions follow the format “thread type (ball material – ball diameter – stem material – stem diameter – overall length)”. For example, M3 Stylus (R-3-SS-1.5-L21) denotes an M3 threaded straight stylus with a 3 mm ruby ball and a 1.5 mm stainless steel stem, 21 mm in overall length. This naming pattern helps engineers quickly interpret stylus specifications, but it cannot be assumed that all part numbers follow this rule — special stylus designs with prefixes such as SV, TI, or DA indicate structural types (disc, joint, cube, etc.), not ball material codes.
The relationship between the thread and the ball material deserves further emphasis. The thread is the interface that determines whether the stylus can be mounted; the ball material is the working surface that determines whether measurement results are reliable. The two cannot substitute for each other, nor can one be inferred from the other. Identifying the probe head first and then selecting the ball material is not a procedural formality — it is a practical safeguard against selection errors. Ruby is the default starting point and covers the vast majority of trigger measurement and light-load scanning applications. Only under specific heavy-load scanning conditions should you evaluate whether to switch to silicon nitride or zirconia based on the workpiece material. As for the exact stylus to choose, always refer to the official data sheet rather than estimating part numbers or parameters from experience.
Adhesive wear can be understood as follows: during scanning, the stylus tip repeatedly contacts and rubs against the aluminium surface, and local contact points generate transient high temperatures. Aluminium has a low melting point and high plasticity. Under the combined effect of pressure and temperature, a small amount of aluminium is torn from the workpiece surface, transferred to the stylus tip, and gradually builds up. This is not the ruby being worn away; it is aluminium sticking to the ruby. Once a layer of aluminium adheres to the tip, the actual shape of the tip changes, and the measured diameter no longer equals the calibrated value. The measured coordinate data will drift progressively. More problematic is that the adhered material is not evenly distributed but accumulates locally, which can significantly degrade repeatability.
Detecting adhesive wear does not require expensive instruments. Remove the stylus from the probe head and inspect the tip surface with the naked eye or a magnifying glass: if grey-white deposits appear on the originally smooth surface, or the surface darkens and no longer reflects light, aluminium transfer has almost certainly occurred. Another indicator is a systematic deviation in the measurement data on the calibration sphere (standard sphere), with the deviation direction related to the scanning path — for example, scanning the same sphere in one direction and then in reverse produces inconsistent results.
However, not all aluminium part measurement requires switching to silicon nitride. The official precondition is clear: heavy duty scanning. For routine touch-trigger probing, small-area point capture, or applications with low scanning speed and low trigger force, ruby is generally fine. The following three scenarios are where caution is genuinely needed:
The first is large-area continuous scanning of deep-cavity or thin-walled aluminium parts. These workpieces typically require the stylus to run long paths along the wall at a large approach angle. The cumulative contact time between the stylus tip and the workpiece is long, frictional heat dissipates poorly, and the risk of adhesion rises sharply. Typical examples include internal cavity inspection of aluminium alloy housings, valve bodies, and motor end caps.
The second is scanning on aluminium blanks or semi-finished parts. Blank surfaces carry oxide scale and residual sand particles, with high surface roughness. Scanning generates high impact loads, and local contact stress far exceeds that on machined surfaces. In this case, the ruby stylus tip may not only pick up aluminium but also develop scratches from hard surface particles.
The third is high-speed scanning. When modern scanning probes (such as the SP25M scanning module) run continuous-path scans on aluminium parts, the relative speed between the stylus tip and the workpiece is high, and frictional heat builds up quickly. The higher the speed, the stronger the tendency to adhesion.
After switching to silicon nitride styli, the improvement is clear. Silicon nitride is a ceramic material with low surface energy, so its affinity for aluminium is far lower than that of ruby. As a result, aluminium does not readily spread or build up on the silicon nitride stylus tip. According to the official physical property data, silicon nitride has a higher compressive strength (3000 MPa) than ruby (2100 MPa), and its fracture toughness (K1c = 6) is also significantly better than ruby’s (K1c = 1). This means that under impact and alternating loads, silicon nitride styli are less prone to micro-cracking. In terms of hardness, silicon nitride (1600 HV) is lower than ruby (2300 HV), but for scanning aluminium parts, hardness is not a limiting factor — aluminium is far softer than either stylus material. The real issue is always adhesion, not wear.
It should be noted that silicon nitride styli are not a “universal solution” for measuring aluminium parts. Their application limits are clearly stated in the official documentation: silicon nitride exhibits noticeable abrasive wear when scanning steel parts. In other words, if a machine measures both aluminium and steel parts and the operator does not change the stylus to save time, the silicon nitride tip will become scratched after running on steel for a while. This degrades sphericity, and accuracy will deteriorate faster than with ruby. Therefore, silicon nitride styli should be treated as a dedicated configuration for heavy-duty scanning of aluminium parts, not as a general-purpose replacement.
In practice, the following approach is recommended for deciding whether to switch to silicon nitride:
Second, observe the current situation. If the ruby stylus tip has already picked up aluminum on an aluminum workpiece, the current conditions have exceeded what ruby can handle, and switching to silicon nitride is the right call. If the ruby tip has been performing well all along, the application is not demanding and there is no need to change it.
Third, assess the risk of mixed-material probing. If the machine measures both aluminum and steel parts on the same day, confirm that the stylus change procedure is smooth before switching to silicon nitride—the stylus must be changed every time the workpiece material changes, which affects cycle time. If the procedure cannot be maintained, it is better to keep the ruby tip and shorten the calibration interval than to let a silicon nitride tip scan steel parts.
One more point worth noting: after changing the stylus tip material, the calibration data will change. Silicon nitride has a lower density (3.0–3.2 g/cm³) than ruby (3.90 g/cm³), so for the same tip diameter, a silicon nitride stylus has less tip mass, which benefits the dynamic performance of the probe head. However, the thermal expansion coefficient also differs with tip material (silicon nitride 3.2×10⁻⁶/°C, ruby 4.5×10⁻⁶/°C), so in a workshop with noticeable temperature variation, calibration values may differ slightly from those of a ruby tip. Therefore, after changing tip material, the stylus must be recalibrated—do not reuse the calibration data from the ruby tip.
A simple rule of thumb: if you are doing continuous scanning on aluminium parts and notice that the calibration sphere data drifts more than normal within a day, or you can see visible deposits on the sphere surface, don’t immediately suspect the probe head or the machine accuracy. First, remove the stylus and inspect the stylus tip. In many cases, the problem is with this small sphere, which is only a few millimetres in diameter. Replacing it with a silicon nitride stylus tip and recalibrating usually brings the data back to normal. Check the official data sheet to confirm whether the stylus model you selected offers a silicon nitride tip option, and note the corresponding part number.
The damage to the stylus tip caused by cast iron workpieces under heavy-duty scanning conditions is completely different from that caused by aluminium parts. With aluminium, the issue is mutual attraction between materials — aluminium chips stick to the ruby stylus tip, which is adhesive wear. With cast iron, the problem lies in its microstructure, which contains high-hardness carbide particles and free graphite. As the stylus tip repeatedly slides over the workpiece surface, these hard particles act like sandpaper, micro-cutting the ruby surface. This is abrasive wear. Although ruby is very hard, prolonged heavy-duty scanning on cast iron will gradually degrade the sphericity of the stylus tip, producing fine scratches and flattened areas that directly affect measurement repeatability.
For this application, the manufacturer’s recommended stylus ball material is zirconia (ZrO₂). It should be noted that this recommendation is explicitly based on “heavy duty scanning”—not all measurements on cast iron require a change of ball material. For light-load trigger probing and discrete point inspection with few points, ruby balls are usually still adequate. Whether a task qualifies as heavy duty scanning can be judged from three aspects: scanning speed, scan path density, and contact force. Only when high-speed continuous scanning, dense scan line spacing, and a large contact force applied by the stylus to the workpiece surface occur simultaneously does the ball material need to be changed.
The applicability limits of zirconia can be understood from its material properties. The manufacturer’s data sheet shows that zirconia has a hardness of 1200 HV—lower than ruby’s 2300 HV and silicon nitride’s 1600 HV—but its fracture toughness is as high as 10, far exceeding ruby’s 1 and silicon nitride’s 6. This means that while zirconia is not as hard as ruby, it is considerably tougher and less prone to microcracking under impact and cyclic loading. In heavy duty scanning of cast iron, hard particles on the workpiece surface cause both abrasive wear (cutting-type) and fatigue damage (repeated impact-type) on the stylus ball. Zirconia’s high fracture toughness directly addresses the latter failure mode. Its compressive strength is 2000 MPa and flexural strength is 1000 MPa—the highest among the three common ball materials—indicating that it is less likely to fracture under bending loads.
But zirconia is not a universal solution. Its density is 6.05 g/cm³, which is significantly higher than that of ruby—the exact value is given in the official data sheet—and it is also the heaviest of the three ball materials. This means that, at the same ball diameter, the end mass of a zirconia ball is greater. For trigger probes, a larger end mass is more likely to cause false triggers during machine movement or vibration; for scanning probes, a heavier ball increases the dynamic inertia of the stylus, affecting its tracking performance during high-speed scanning. Zirconia balls are therefore typically used with shorter styli to limit the effect of end mass on dynamic measurement performance. If the measurement task requires a long stylus to reach the feature, even on a cast iron workpiece, the suitability of zirconia should be reconsidered—in such cases, it is safer to adjust the measurement strategy rather than simply increasing the ball diameter or lengthening the stylus.
Another easily overlooked boundary is the thermal expansion coefficient of zirconia. Its thermal expansion is 10.5×10⁻⁶/°C, significantly higher than ruby’s 4.5×10⁻⁶/°C and silicon nitride’s 3.2×10⁻⁶/°C. In a workshop where temperatures vary widely, the size of zirconia balls changes more with temperature than ruby balls. For high-accuracy measurement tasks, if ambient temperature swings exceed the equipment’s allowable range, the dimensional stability of zirconia balls can become a limiting factor. Of course, CMMs usually have temperature compensation, so the actual effect depends on the machine configuration—but this should still be kept in mind when choosing ball material.
Another common misconception needs clearing up: choosing between zirconia and silicon nitride is not about “which is better” but about which suits the application. Silicon nitride is strictly for heavy-duty scanning of aluminium parts; zirconia is for heavy-duty scanning of cast iron. The two are not interchangeable—using zirconia on aluminium may not solve adhesive wear because of its higher density and lower hardness, and using silicon nitride on cast iron is not recommended: the manufacturer explicitly notes significant abrasive wear when scanning steel, and for cast iron the official recommendation is zirconia. So the first step in selecting ball material is always to confirm the workpiece material and scanning conditions, not to see what balls you already have on hand.
The sphericity grade of zirconia balls is the same as that of ruby balls, with the official standard being Grade 5, offering a sphericity of 0.13 µm. If higher precision is required, Grade 3 balls with a sphericity of 0.08 µm are available. However, Grade 3 balls use a non-drilled bonding process and are structurally different from conventional drilled balls; specific compatibility should be confirmed against the official data sheet. When ordering, stylus descriptions follow a unified naming protocol. For example, a straight stylus with M3 thread, zirconia ball, and stainless steel rod will have its description clearly indicating the ball material code. Use this code to look up the part number rather than trying to deduce the numbering pattern yourself.
The drawback of silicon nitride balls is stated plainly in official documentation: when scanning on steel parts, silicon nitride balls exhibit significant abrasive wear. Abrasive wear and adhesive wear are two entirely different failure mechanisms. Adhesive wear involves microscopic “cold welding” between two materials under contact pressure, causing one material to transfer onto the surface of the other. Abrasive wear, by contrast, occurs when hard particles or a hard surface cut grooves into the ball, gradually wearing away the material like sandpaper. The silicon nitride–steel material pair is particularly prone to the latter.
Material properties offer some clues. Silicon nitride has a hardness of about 1600 HV, a flexural strength of 850 MPa, and a fracture toughness K1c of 6—these values are not low for ceramic balls, and are in fact considerably higher than the toughness of ruby (fracture toughness K1c of 1). But hardness is not the only factor governing wear behaviour. The chemical affinity between silicon nitride and steel in a friction pair, the surface roughness match, and the micro-stress state in the contact zone together determine that it is not suited to prolonged high-speed contact with steel. The manufacturer’s conclusion is clear: silicon nitride should be limited to aluminium applications. This is not conservatism; it is based on the actual performance of the material pairing.
A typical misuse scenario is this: a shop machines both aluminium alloy housings and steel structural parts. To save time, the engineers fit silicon nitride styli to all probes, reasoning that “a ceramic ball is always more wear-resistant than ruby.” On aluminium, silicon nitride performs well and adhesive wear is effectively suppressed. But when the same stylus is used to scan steel—especially under heavy scanning loads—the silicon nitride ball gradually shows signs of abrasive wear. The ball surface loses its smoothness, sphericity degrades, and measurement repeatability starts to drift. What makes this worse is that abrasive wear is not visible to the naked eye the way adhesive wear is: aluminium swarf builds up on the ball surface and is spotted and wiped off at a glance. Abrasive wear, by contrast, is actual loss of ball material—by the time the data looks wrong, the ball may already be worn to the point of needing replacement.
Whether silicon nitride is the right choice depends not only on the workpiece material but also on the measuring conditions. Both official recommendations state the prerequisite as “heavy duty scanning” — not every aluminium part needs silicon nitride. Conversely, silicon nitride is not suitable for steel parts, regardless of whether heavy duty scanning is involved. If ruby balls wear on steel parts, the solution is not to switch to silicon nitride; instead, look at parameters such as stylus length, ball diameter, scanning speed and trigger force, or consider other stylus tip materials. The limitations of silicon nitride on steel make it a “special-purpose key”, not a “universal key”.
Another point that is easy to confuse: abrasive wear of silicon nitride balls on steel and abrasive wear of ruby balls on cast iron are both called “abrasive wear”, but the mechanisms and severity differ. Ruby balls wear on cast iron because free carbide particles in the cast iron are extremely hard and can scratch micro-cracks on the ruby surface. Silicon nitride balls wear on steel mainly because the two materials are mismatched in the friction pair. The former is caused by “foreign hard particles”, the latter by “improper material pairing”. So just because silicon nitride handles adhesive wear on aluminium, it does not follow that it protects against wear on all metal workpieces.
In practice, if a machine measures both aluminium and steel parts, the safest approach is to prepare two stylus kits and switch between them according to workpiece material. One kit uses silicon nitride stylus tips for heavy-duty scanning of aluminium parts; the other uses ruby stylus tips for routine measurement and steel parts. This does increase the variety of spare parts, but it avoids data anomalies caused by using the wrong stylus tip material and the extra work of frequent stylus changes. When switching, note that the stylus must be recalibrated after replacement, because even small differences in stylus tip diameter and stylus length can affect measurement results.
Finally, back to the selection principles themselves. The manufacturer repeatedly stresses: use the shortest stylus that meets the application, minimise the number of joints, and use the largest stylus tip possible. These three principles apply equally to stylus tip material selection. Silicon nitride stylus tips are not a “premium option” — they are functional components for specific conditions. They solve adhesive wear problems in heavy-duty scanning of aluminium parts, but on steel they introduce abrasive wear. Limiting their use to aluminium is not to undervalue the material, but to let each stylus work in the conditions it handles best. When choosing a stylus tip material, ask yourself three questions: What is the workpiece material? Is this heavy-duty scanning? Has the ruby stylus tip already shown wear? Only when all three answers point to heavy-duty scanning of aluminium does silicon nitride come into play. Otherwise, ruby remains the default starting point for the vast majority of applications.
The first trap: dropping the “heavy-duty scanning” premise.
When the manufacturer gives stylus tip material recommendations for adhesive wear on aluminum parts and abrasive wear on cast iron parts, they always carry an explicit premise — heavy-duty scanning. Not every aluminum or cast iron part needs a different stylus tip material. If the measuring program uses trigger-style point capture, contact between the stylus tip and the workpiece is intermittent point contact, with low contact force and short contact time, so a ruby stylus tip is fully adequate. Only under continuous scanning, where the stylus tip slides at high speed over the workpiece surface under significant contact load, does the interaction between materials accumulate to a visibly worn level. The right question is therefore not “is the workpiece aluminum?” but “is this aluminum measurement task heavy-duty scanning?” For routine dimensional measurement, ruby remains the default starting point — there is no need to switch to silicon nitride simply because the workpiece is aluminum.
The second trap: looking only at workpiece material, not the wear mechanism.
The wear patterns on cast iron differ between rough-machined and fine-machined surfaces. Hard particles and residual sand on rough surfaces cause abrasive wear on any stylus tip material. In contrast, the interaction between a relatively smooth cast iron surface and ruby under heavy scanning is the type of wear that the manufacturer recommends replacing with zirconia. Conversely, silicon nitride tips exhibit significant abrasive wear when scanning steel parts—this is clearly documented by the manufacturer. In other words, if a machine measures both aluminium and steel parts, fitting silicon nitride tips simply because the workpiece is aluminium will actually accelerate tip wear when switching to steel tasks. The applicable range of tip material is defined by the “tip material–workpiece” pairing, not by a single workpiece material.
The third trap: ignoring the constraints of probe model on selection.
Choosing the right stylus ball material is only part of the story—if the thread is wrong, the stylus won’t fit. The thread type follows the probe, not the CMM brand. Many domestic CMM brands and some imported models use the Renishaw probe head/controller system, so knowing the CMM brand alone doesn’t tell you the thread specification. The correct selection order is: first identify the probe head model, then determine the thread, then the ball diameter and length, and finally the ball material. A common real-world mistake is that engineers select the ball material based on the workpiece material, find silicon nitride, but overlook whether the probe is trigger or scanning type and whether the thread is M2 or M3. As a result, the purchased stylus either doesn’t fit, or if it does fit, the probe module doesn’t support scanning operation at all. Ball material is only one factor in stylus selection—it cannot be decided independently of the probe system.
The fourth trap: treating the ball material recommendation as “applicable to all similar workpieces”.
The official section on stylus tip materials is deliberately restrained: ruby is suitable for the vast majority of applications, with only two exceptions — silicon nitride is recommended for heavy-duty scanning of aluminium parts, and zirconia for heavy-duty scanning of cast iron parts. However, these recommendations do not specify quantitative thresholds such as “after how many hours of scanning aluminium parts must the stylus be changed” or “above what surface roughness of cast iron parts must it be replaced”. Real-world conditions vary widely: for the same aluminium part, some shops use cutting fluid, others cut dry; some surfaces are anodised, others are bare. All of these factors affect when adhesive wear begins. Stylus tip selection is therefore not a one-off decision — it should be adjusted dynamically based on the actual machine configuration and on-site wear inspection. If aluminium build-up or cast-iron scratches are found on the ruby stylus tip, assessing whether to switch to the corresponding material is a safer approach than applying a blanket rule in advance.
The fifth trap: inferring from the workpiece material while ignoring the differences in the physical properties of the stylus tip material.
Silicon nitride and zirconia are not “upgraded” versions of ruby, but alternative materials for specific applications. According to the official property data, ruby has a hardness of HV 2300, silicon nitride HV 1600, and zirconia HV 1200 — both of the latter are softer than ruby. They are suitable for certain applications not because they are harder, but because they interact differently with aluminium and cast iron. Silicon nitride is less prone to material transfer with aluminium, and zirconia’s fracture toughness (K1c = 10) is far higher than ruby’s (K1c = 1), making it less susceptible to micro-cracking under intermittent impact on cast iron. If you assume “the workpiece is cast iron, so zirconia is harder and therefore more wear-resistant”, you have it exactly backwards. Zirconia’s wear resistance comes from its toughness and surface characteristics, not its hardness. Likewise, silicon nitride’s advantage on aluminium parts is resistance to adhesion, not resistance to abrasive wear. Using silicon nitride on steel parts will cause rapid wear due to abrasive action.
A practical way to decide:
When the shop floor asks whether to switch stylus tip material, check in this order:
Not necessarily, but you first need to confirm whether your application is “heavy-duty scanning”. Ruby is suitable for the vast majority of applications — the manufacturer’s own wording is that “there are very few applications where ruby is not suitable”. However, if you are heavy-duty scanning aluminium — for example, high feed rates, high speeds, or long continuous scanning — the ruby ball and the aluminium can attract each other, causing adhesive wear. Aluminium will build up on the ball, and the measurement data will start to drift. The check is simple: regularly inspect the stylus tip for a whitish or roughened surface, or watch for a steadily increasing value when calibrating the ball diameter — both are signs of adhesive wear. If you only probe a few aluminium features occasionally and with light force, ruby is perfectly adequate and there is no need to change. If heavy-duty scanning is confirmed, switch to a silicon nitride ball. Note that silicon nitride is intended for aluminium only — do not use it on steel, as it will show significant abrasive wear on steel.
Your approach is correct, but there are two things to watch. First, the thread must match. Check whether your probe head uses an M2 or M3 thread—styli with different threads cannot be mixed. This depends on the probe head model, not the machine tool brand. Second, you must recalibrate after every stylus change. Each time you swap styli, the ball diameter and position change; measuring without recalibration gives inaccurate data. Also, silicon nitride and zirconia are intended for heavy-duty scanning, not for all aluminum or cast iron parts. If your aluminum parts are only measured under light load, ruby is fine. For cast iron, ruby can also handle occasional scanning. Only when you do heavy-duty scanning on cast iron and notice abrasive wear on the ruby ball (dull or scratched surface) should you switch to zirconia. A more practical approach is to keep ruby as the default and use silicon nitride and zirconia as backups, switching based on workpiece material and cutting conditions.
It is not recommended to make do with it. The official documentation clearly states that silicon nitride exhibits significant abrasive wear when scanning steel parts. Abrasive wear differs from adhesive wear: adhesive wear involves material transfer, while abrasive wear occurs when the stylus tip surface is scratched by hard particles. Silicon nitride has a hardness of HV1600, considerably lower than ruby’s HV2300, so when scanning steel parts, the surface gradually roughens, sphericity degrades, and measurement data becomes unstable. If you only occasionally scan one or two steel features, the effect may not be noticeable for a while, but wear is irreversible—by the time you notice a drop in accuracy, the stylus is essentially finished. So either you strictly segregate styli by material—use silicon nitride for aluminum parts and switch back to ruby for steel—or you avoid silicon nitride altogether, using it only temporarily for heavy-load scanning of aluminum parts and swapping it out afterward. Don’t expect a single stylus to handle all materials.
The officially recommended application for zirconia is heavy-duty scanning of cast iron; there is no official basis for its use on aluminium parts. Zirconia has a hardness of HV1200, which is lower than that of ruby and silicon nitride. The core issue in heavy-duty scanning of aluminium parts is adhesion, and zirconia’s surface characteristics do not address this problem. In addition, zirconia has a density of 6.05 g/cm³, considerably higher than ruby’s 3.90 g/cm³, so for the same stylus tip diameter it is heavier and demands greater stylus rigidity. The most straightforward approach is therefore to select the stylus tip material according to the workpiece: silicon nitride for heavy-duty aluminium, zirconia for heavy-duty cast iron, and ruby for general applications. Keep one stylus of each tip material and switch them based on the workpiece — do not expect a single stylus to cover all cases.
The judgment criteria are the stylus tip condition and the calibration data. On aluminium parts, the main risk with ruby is adhesive wear — aluminium sticks to the ball and builds up. You can see the ball surface turning white and dull with the naked eye, or see aluminium residue under a magnifying glass. At this stage, wiping with alcohol will not remove it, because the aluminium has already undergone material transfer with the ball surface. When calibrating the stylus tip diameter, if the value keeps coming out larger than expected, material has built up on the ball. On cast iron parts, the main risk with ruby is abrasive wear — hard particles in the cast iron scratch the ball surface, making it lose its shine and show fine scratches to the naked eye. The calibrated ball diameter will then tend to come out smaller. Once either of these conditions appears, the ruby stylus is no longer suitable for the current application and should be replaced with silicon nitride (for aluminium) or zirconia (for cast iron). One more note: if you are only taking occasional point measurements rather than running long, heavy scanning cycles, ruby is usually fine — there is no need to overreact.
Don’t worry about the machine brand for now—start with the probe model. The thread type follows the probe, not the machine brand. For example, Renishaw’s TP20 and TP200 use M2 threads, the SP25M uses M3, and the TP7M uses M4—these are specified in the official catalogs. Hexagon’s catalog is also split into trigger and scanning types: trigger types cover M2, M3, and M4, while scanning types include D2 (no thread), M3, and M5. So the first step is to locate the probe model on the machine and confirm whether it’s M2, M3, or M4. Once the thread is confirmed, check the official data sheets by ball material and diameter to see if a matching part number exists. Both manufacturers provide cross-reference tables, so Renishaw and Hexagon part numbers can be looked up against each other, but you cannot assume combinations that aren’t listed. If you’re unsure, send the probe model, ball material, and ball diameter to your supplier and let them verify it. Don’t order based only on the machine brand—that’s an easy way to end up with the wrong thread.
Choosing the stylus tip material is not really a materials-science question—it is an engineering question of “friction-pair matching.” Rather than memorizing a lookup table that pairs aluminum with silicon nitride and cast iron with zirconia, it is more useful to learn one rule you can apply immediately: first determine whether the task is heavy-duty scanning, then identify the wear type based on the workpiece material. In practice, you only need to ask yourself three questions. First, does the current measurement task involve heavy-duty scanning? If not, a ruby stylus tip is a perfectly adequate default. Second, if it is heavy-duty scanning, is the workpiece aluminum or cast iron? Aluminum causes adhesive wear; cast iron causes abrasive wear. Third, has the corresponding wear pattern already appeared on the ruby stylus tip? Aluminum build-up indicates adhesive wear; scratches and loss of gloss indicate abrasive wear. Using the official definition of “heavy-duty scanning” and the wear patterns, choose silicon nitride for heavy-duty scanning of aluminum parts and zirconia for heavy-duty scanning of cast iron parts. If the application falls outside the range covered by ruby, silicon nitride, and zirconia, refer to the official data sheet. When selecting a stylus tip material, first confirm the probe model and thread specification, then confirm whether the application is heavy-duty scanning, and finally inspect the wear pattern on the ruby stylus tip. Only after checking these boundaries should you make your selection.
Every machine tool has different configuration, operating conditions, and budget. This article is only a reference framework. You can:
Ningbo JCETech — 15 years focused on precision measurement, covering selection, installation, calibration, repair, and maintenance for the full range of Renishaw, Marposs, and Blum-Novotest probes and tool setters.
| Contact Information | Details |
|---|---|
| Official booking | jcetech.cn/contact |
| Hotline | 157-5780-7400 / 132-2194-1413 |
| Repair shipping address | Ningbo Yinzhou R&D Park A2-12B17 |
| Service coverage | Nationwide on-site service · 48-hour response for urgent repairs |
Send us your problem and let our engineers help you work out the numbers.
If the criteria or procedures in this article do not match your machine, send us the control system, probe model and a photo of the installation — we will answer with the specific settings rather than a generic recommendation.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Company | NINGBO JCE INDUSTRIAL TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. (JCETech) |
| Address | Room 14-1-17, Building 033, Building 2, No. 15, Lane 587 Juxian Road, Juxian Subdistrict, Hi-Tech Zone, Ningbo 315048, Zhejiang, P.R. China |
| Contact | Mr. Li / Mr. Zhang |
| Phone | +86 157-5780-7400 (Mr. Li), +86 132-2194-1413 (Mr. Zhang) |
| Online booking | jcetech.cn/contact |
Repair intake and on-site service use the same address. Please call before shipping a unit so transport and scheduling do not have to be repeated.
Probe, tool setter and laser interferometer repair, calibration and on-machine measurement integration.
157-5780-7400 / 132-2194-1413
打开微信扫一扫,关注「宁波匠测」
获取维修进度查询与技术支持
打开企业微信或微信扫一扫
添加专属顾问,随时沟通